|
|||
|
To an Algerian Woman Reader Supporter of ‘Che’ Guevara’s Anti-Imperialist Strategy |
|||
| (Programme Communiste, No. 39, July-September 1967)
|
You wrote to us to express your disappointment at our criticism of Che Guevara’s anti-imperialist strategy (the proliferation of Vietnams) in the June issue of Le Prolétaire. At the same time, you expressed the mistrust that we, as Europeans and, worse still, Frenchmen, inspire in you, even when we are communists, even when we denounce the P.C.F. This mistrust is all too justified by history. Yet serious revolutionary politics cannot be based on feelings; whether European or not, no sincere anti-imperialist is exempt from studying the Marxist answer to the great political question of the 20th century: how to liberate the world from imperialist oppression?
You could have gained a very clear insight into this answer from the article you are criticising, had the mentality of the ‘European revolutionary’ (that is to say, of the proletarian internationalist) not been completely unfamiliar to you.
An example of this misunderstanding, incidentally quite understandable, is that you write at the end of your letter: ‘I hope you will forgive me for a few harsh words’. But what words are you referring to? ‘The European proletariat has been domesticated since the First World War, and the workers’ leaderships have become a sort of mafia’. ‘Today, the European and French proletariat has nothing revolutionary about it; it is merely reformist and petty-bourgeois’. For a party which, like ours, has been fighting for half a century against all forms of the proletariat’s political subjugation to the imperialist bourgeoisie; for a party that has denounced not only the Social-Democratic betrayal of 1914, but all those, even worse, that followed and which ruined the Third International, these are not ‘harsh revelations’! It is simply a brief account of the defeats it has suffered and the obstacles it still faces today within the proletariat itself, that is all.
What, then, is there to ‘forgive’? The fact that ‘underdeveloped’ people ‘speak their minds’ to ‘advanced’ ones, as you yourself suggest? That is really to be completely ignorant of our traditions. When, after 1917, the first Bolshevik appeals for a resolute anti-capitalist struggle and for the reconstitution of the revolutionary International came from backward Russia, the ‘distinguished’ reformists of Western Europe protested that they had no lessons in socialism to learn from these ‘underdeveloped’ Russians who had only just rid themselves of tsarism. They, social-patriotic lackeys of the imperialist bourgeoisie, regarded the Revolution with the foolish disdain of so-called ‘advanced socialists’, infatuated with their ‘Western culture’ and their ‘great peaceful achievements’. And we, fifty years on, would have the same psychology (more or less...) even whilst defending the political and theoretical positions of their revolutionary opponents of the time: Russian Bolsheviks, German Spartacists (whom they crushed in a bloodbath!), the abstentionist Italian communists, etc. Judge for yourself how implausible this is!
Yet, instinctively, you attribute our criticism of Guevara to a ‘French and European messianism’, even to a pacifism of peoples sated and stupefied by the American way of life.
‘European messianism’, what is it? It is impossible to answer in the abstract, in general terms: one must take into account the class positions at play. For the bourgeoisie, this ‘messianism’ is easy to define: it claimed to open the paradise of civilisation to all the peoples of the world, whilst in reality it was plunging them into the capitalist hell. When the revolutionary effects of its expansion manifested themselves in violent movements for national independence, it resisted them with all its might and as best it could, claiming that these peoples could not do without its tutelage in order to ‘govern themselves’. Today, now that the European bourgeoisie, having taken a back seat, has lost much of its former grandeur, it is the U.S.A. that plays this role of ‘Messiah’. As for workers’ opportunism, it has never done anything but share the bourgeois prejudices regarding the ‘progressive’ virtues of capitalist democracy and introduce them, under the most varied guises, into the proletariat. The most shameful example of this pernicious work is that of the P.C.F. and the P.C.A., claiming that, since the achievement of Algeria’s political independence was subordinate to the workers’ revolution in France, one should not rise up against French imperialism, but wait for the said revolution. If the P.C.F. had genuinely fought for the proletarian revolution in France, it would never have defended such an absurd ‘theory’, nor played such an obstructive role. But since it is a party of conservation, a fierce enemy of social revolution and indeed of any class position, its despicable arguments against the Algerian insurrection should not be taken as proof of a ‘European messianism’ specific to the workers’ camp! It must be taken for the only thing it really is: the shameless exploitation of revolutionary and class phraseology against any change to the established order.
That said, within the authentically revolutionary camp, can one speak of a ‘European messianism’? Even the most revolutionary texts (for example, the Manifesto of the Communist International to the proletarians of the whole world in 1919) may give this impression to those who, having suffered, as you have, from long-standing imperialist oppression, read them not in a class spirit, but in that of a humiliated nationalism. You may, for example, take offence at this extract from the Manifesto cited above, which, for us, remains as relevant as ever, but which all the currents calling themselves ‘communist’ have betrayed: ‘Only the proletarian revolution can secure the existence of the small nations, a revolution which frees the productive forces of all countries from the restrictions of the national states, which unites all peoples in the closest economic cooperation on the basis of a universal economic plan (...) Capitalist Europe has drawn the backward countries by force into the capitalist whirlpool, and socialist Europe will come to the aid of the liberated colonies with its technique, its organization, its spiritual influence, in order to facilitate their transition into the orderly system of socialist economy’. Whilst there is indeed mention here of a ‘mission of Europe’, this is entirely secondary, linked solely to the only notion which, for Marxism, is fundamental and immutable: that of the historical mission of the revolutionary proletariat and of socialism. The fact that the European working class did not live up to the hopes that the International of 1919 had placed in it, when it expected that it would know how to break with the Social Democrats and storm the bourgeois powers, in no way detracts from the correctness of the thesis implied here and developed a hundred times over in authentic Marxist literature: the attainment of political independence is not true liberation for a former colony or semi-colony because the economic laws of capitalism will in any case hinder the development of the productive forces there. Only socialism, by enabling genuine cooperation (impossible as long as the economic aim is profit, even if Capital does not fail to use the word), will liberate the poorest countries from their economic backwardness. To fail to recognise this would not only be to ignore the terrible reality of today, where the economic gap between developed and underdeveloped countries continues to widen: it would be to pay a rather superficial and unwitting tribute to Capital as a mode of production and exchange!
If we, proletarian internationalists, are so committed to this central thesis: without a communist revolution in the advanced countries, there can be no liberation of underdeveloped countries from poverty and oppression, it is by no means out of contempt for the underdeveloped peoples, but out of hatred for the saccharine lies of capitalism in the phase of decolonisation; and we are all the more at ease in denouncing them, these lies, because we have joyfully welcomed all the insurrectionary and armed movements against the old colonialist metropolises and pilloried all those who denied the colonies their right to secession. Consequently, you are perfectly ‘free’ to imitate, if you so wish, our bourgeois, who, for over a century, have mocked Marxist ‘mysticism’, revolutionary ‘utopianism’ assigning a historical role to the proletariat: but you have no right to lump this doctrine together haphazardly with the worst lies of the colonialist imperialism of yesteryear under the banner of ‘European messianism’.
The Marxist notion of the proletariat’s historical mission has, of course, nothing mystical about it, but derives both from the scientific interpretation of history as the history of the class struggle and from the scientific critique of capitalism as an economy based not on equal exchange, but on the extraction of surplus value from producers and generalised dispossession. The Third International’s assessment in 1919 that the centre of the global class struggle lay in Europe likewise corresponded to a political reality, and not to any a priori whatever, and certainly not a racist one! As Europe had been by far the continent hardest hit by the imperialist war, it was there that not only the first communist revolution had taken place, but also the first political struggles of the working class against the bourgeoisie responsible for the conflict; and at the same time, it was there that the International had its main parties. In 1919, it believed the days of reformist opportunism were numbered and generally saw the revolution as imminent: now, a Europe composed of red republics, a Europe dominated by the communist proletariat, would undoubtedly have acted as a catalyst for the movement for the emancipation of the colonies, then in its infancy or non-existent, firstly; and secondly, it would just as undoubtedly have put an end to the exploitation to which the bourgeoisie had subjected them. This latter assessment is indisputably correct, colonial and imperialist oppression being inscribed in the mode of production and the political domination of the bourgeoisie, not in some vague ‘will to power’ on the part of the white race or of European peoples as such. The error concerned solely the time-scale of the revolutionary process: if there was any ‘messianism’ at all, it was solely that of a generation of proletarian internationalists who, in a revolutionary enthusiasm that was, incidentally, commendable, were able to believe for a few years that the honour of overthrowing capitalism would fall to them.
What is the situation today? Since we cannot abandon the notion of the proletariat’s historical mission, which is rooted in doctrine and cannot therefore be undermined by a mere historical delay, do we also continue to believe that the centre of the revolutionary proletarian struggle will be Europe, in the reality of tomorrow, just as in the optimistic outlook of our comrades in 1919? For us, this is merely a historical probability linked to the following two considerations: the inevitable global capitalist crisis must strike the developed capitalist countries harder than the others; but amongst those it will hit hard (the U.S.A. – Europe – Japan), it is those where there is a minimum of revolutionary continuity, that is, where there are internationalist parties, even if they are still very weak today, that have the greatest chance of entering into revolutionary fermentation, and not those where the proletariat has never yet had a political tradition of its own; and therefore Europe rather than the U.S.A. or Japan. This probability sustains our courage in the vastly unequal struggle we are waging, and it does not blind us to the point of failing to recognise the proletarian and communist Revolution wherever it may break out, should it break out elsewhere. In what way, then, is it dangerous, and what is so messianic about it? In the last century, the centre of proletarian struggle shifted successively from France, to Germany, then to Eastern Europe and, above all, to Russia: this never posed any particular problem for Marxists, who claimed so little of a ‘national’, even revolutionary, monopoly that it was German Marxists, and not Russian ones, who were the first to recognise this latest shift. (It is true that the pre-Marxist French socialists believed themselves to be eternally entrusted with a special mission within the labour movement, on the pretext that the bourgeois revolution in France had, in the past, shone with particular brilliance; but since Marx himself demolished this claim with the arguments of historical materialism, it is he whom we consider to have been right, not our ‘compatriots’ of the time!) In our own century, it is not mathematically ruled out that this revolutionary centre may leave Europe for another continent; it would be even less so if the communist revolution were to be delayed for another half-century, into the... 21st century. The only thing that is ruled out is that the world should be liberated from imperialist oppression without a social revolution by the proletariat... ‘Mathematically’ ruled out. And if we refuse to subscribe to Che Guevara’s strategy, it is not because he speaks to us of America, but because he does not speak... ‘Bolshevik’.
Might the basis of our criticism, then, be a form of pacifism on the part of the inhabitants of developed countries, terrified by the bloody proposal to multiply Vietnams, the last of your suggestions? Not at all. Pacifists of this sort would not hold up as an example to the proletariat a revolution such as the Russian Revolution, which, under the worst possible conditions, waged a civil war lasting more than three years and of the bloodiest kind, rather than surrender the power it had won in the international interests of the proletariat to the imperialist interventionist forces and the counter-revolutionary forces of Russia. Conversely, if we have always fought, are fighting, and will continue to fight against any imperialist war (and a general war in which Russia were to take part, even in the name of the ‘freedom’ of peoples oppressed by the U.S.A., would undeniably be imperialist, just like that of 1940–1945), it is not because we are opposed to violence, but because we intend to counter the reactionary violence of imperialism with the fecund violence of social revolution.
It is precisely because we are genuine revolutionaries, not pacifists, that we have often held up as an example to French and European proletarians, deprived of all fighting energy, the aptitude of the ‘underdeveloped’ for armed revolt (just as Lenin, for the same reasons, entitled a 1913 article ‘Backward Europe and Advanced Asia’). The converse is not true: it is not because one denounces the inaptitude of the former and glorifies the energy of the latter that one necessarily deserves the title of revolutionary.
The revolution requires not only the instinct to revolt and courage; it requires political consciousness. And what must one be conscious of? Of the fact that the alternative of the century is, and remains, either a global social revolution or a new imperialist war? And if the former does not prevent the latter: Transformation of the imperialist war into civil war, or a new imperialist redivision of the world? There is no way out of this.
When one possesses this consciousness, it is equally clear that the profoundly reactionary situation in which the whole world is currently suffocating is characterised not by a single feature, but by two fundamental features; not merely, as you seem to believe, by the fact that the proletariat of the advanced countries, corrupted by pacifism, now appears incapable of preventing a new imperialist war by unleashing its own social war; but also by the fact, which you wish to ignore, that the oppressed in underdeveloped countries, who are themselves waging a social war, harbour an insane faith in imperialist war (the much-called-for clash between Russia and the USA) for the triumph of their cause. Such is the dual basis of the political strength of imperialism; such is the dual bulwark of popular illusions and errors that protects capitalist conservation. Consequence: the political struggle must be waged in such a way as to bring down this dual bulwark.
It is pleasant and easy to be ironic about the pacifism of the proletariats of developed countries: it is incredibly difficult to combat it consistently. It is tempting to explain it by the relative economic prosperity of these countries and to denounce, in a nutshell, ‘corruption by the refrigerator and the washing machine’; yet it is necessary to recognise that it also has deep historical roots in the two imperialist wars which, in half a century, deeply scarred the European peoples, and in the defeats of the workers’ insurrections. It is hasty and, on the surface, magnificently bold to say: ‘the chances of social revolution are nil in the advanced countries; never mind that, we shall do without it’. The trouble is that this is false. All this, forgive us, is not the language of a serious anti-imperialism, but that of anti-imperialist folklore, a worthy counterpart to the pacifist and democratic folklore of Europe and America. And it is precisely because we are not ‘European messianists’, precisely because we believe that the underdeveloped have a revolutionary role to play, precisely because we do not lightly believe that ‘we shall do without them’ that we address them as well as the proletarians of the advanced countries to say to them all: let us fight together for social revolution; let us rebuild together a proletarian and revolutionary International that is not primarily European, but global. We are the only ones doing this. And we are doing it because it is the only policy capable of breaking down not just the single, but the double bulwark of capitalist and imperialist conservation.
To conclude this chapter on ‘pacifism’, one crucial point remains to be considered: pacifism, from a Marxist point of view, is not merely a preference for non-violent methods; it is the belief in a non-violent resolution of social contradictions and of national and imperial contradictions. Now, is it not singularly pacifist in one’s historical foresight to write off both, in advance, the proletarian revolution and the imperialist war, and to conceive of no other possible armed struggles than those of small, underdeveloped nations against Yankee imperialism? To believe this, is it not to believe in an eternal peaceful resolution of the Capital-Labour conflict? In an eternal peaceful resolution of imperialist conflicts? Do you not see that this is precisely the theoretical error underpinning the pacifist and reformist lie of our social-traitors in Europe? Do you not see that ‘anti-imperialist’ propaganda of this kind, far from helping the European proletariat to ‘regenerate’ itself, merely reinforces its foolish complacency, in its fatal conviction that the era of imperialist wars is over, and that social contradictions will resolve themselves, without revolution?
We noted earlier that the bulwark of capitalist conservation is twofold: the pacifism of the ‘advanced’ proletariats, but also the non-proletarian, non-revolutionary nature of the violence advocated by the ‘underdeveloped’. Here we can see why: the ‘pacifism of method’ practised by the former is matched by the ‘pacifism of expectation’ practised by the latter. Imperialism reaps the full political benefit from this. It exploits the passivity of the advanced proletariat in order to crush the small peoples; but it exploits the propaganda of the ‘underdeveloped’ in order to pass itself off as the guardian of peace!
The conclusion is that, whilst one is perfectly free to reject Marxism and proletarian internationalism, and perfectly free to embrace a Guevarist brand of anti-imperialism, one has no right to do so in the name of anti-pacifism.
* * *
That said, what else can we do but stand by the theses set out in our article in their entirety, whilst asking you to look to our other newspaper and journal articles on imperialism for more detailed analysis?
Imperialism is simply capitalism at its final stage of development; it is the inevitable product of the full development of Capitalism. It is overthrown by revolution, not by war, because war alters the balance of forces between powers but leaves capitalist relations of production intact, which only social revolution destroys.
Anti-imperialism à la Che Guevara reproduces two very old and well-known revisionist errors. The first is an implicit theory of ‘super-imperialism’, that is to say, the false idea of a solidarity amongst the major developed capitalist powers for the exploitation and oppression of the Third World. Our position in this regard is that of Lenin, which we can only summarise with this passage taken from his Imperialism, the Highest Stage of Capitalism:
‘Therefore, in the realities of the capitalist system, and not in the banal philistine fantasies of English parsons, or of the German “Marxist,” Kautsky, “inter-imperialist” or “ultra-imperialist” alliances, no matter what form they may assume, whether of one imperialist coalition against another, or of a general alliance embracing all the imperialist powers, are inevitably nothing more than a “truce” in periods between wars’.
The second is the age-old thesis of all the so-called socialists and communists who, for the past fifty years, have betrayed proletarian internationalism: bring down such-and-such an imperialist ‘stronghold’ (yesterday Nazi Germany, today the USA!) and you will thereby weaken imperialism itself. There is no need to resort to theory to refute this: history alone suffices. The role of the imperialist despot of the world changes hands: Imperialism remains. And no force in the world will have the power to crush militarily the last and most powerful imperialist despot in history, save the one force that is its equal: the armed revolutionary proletariat of the whole world!
Making due allowance, Guevarist anti-imperialism is nothing more than a global transposition of the anarchist conception of revolution through the multiplication of armed raids by determined minorities, independent of the class struggle. A romantic position that may seem appealing, but how fragile and inconsistent, and which Marxism refuted once and for all... in the last century. We cannot, therefore, in any way, endorse Che Guevara’s ‘anti-imperialist’ strategy: militants of the social revolution, proletarian internationalists, we are and we remain, because it is the only position that is not unrealistic and that does not lead to defeatism towards the proletariat.